The Elie Wiesel Living Archive

at The 92nd Street Y, New York. Supported by The Elie Wiesel Foundation for Humanity

In the Bible: Lot's Wife

The Limits of Collective Guilt

Oct 03, 1991

In the first lecture of the 25th year, the ancient sinful city of Sodom is doomed, slated for destruction. But what about teshuvah, repentance? Even Abraham argues to save Sodom because of the righteous but for some reason he doesn’t try to awaken repentance. Why? As the Midrash illuminates, Sodom was the cosmic capital of crime, bad toward its inhabitants but worse to strangers. Still, was everyone guilty? Is there in Judaism a notion of collective guilt and punishment? And if so, why should Lot and his family, also inhabitants of Sodom, escape it? On one level, the main participants in the Sodomite drama all appear faulted. Lot is ready to give away his daughters; Lot’s wife plays a role in endangering the angelic guests; the angels are impatient and stingy with miracles; Abraham disappears from the scene and gives in to God. Yet from another vantage point the participants appear in a positive light: Abraham’s intervention shows the error in the notion of collective guilt. And Lot’s wife looked back at the doomed out of maternal love and compassion. The daughters who seduced Lot thought of humankind’s future. And even Lot, who seems so compromised, ends up saving a city: something that Abraham couldn’t do. If Sodom symbolizes hate and indifference to victims, Lot’s wife teaches the lesson that at times “one must look backwards, lest one run the risk of turning into a statue. Of salt, of stone? No. Of ice.”

Selected Quotes:
Books:
Subthemes:
1) The Story of Sodom
2) An Argument with Abraham
3) 25 Years at the 92Y
4) Sodom: Torture
5) Assaulting All Living Creatures in Sodom
6) Why Was Lot, Abraham’s Nephew, Appointed Sodom's Chief Justice?
7) Lot and Sodom
8) The Angels: One More Miracle?
9) Abraham: Why Didn’t He Fight More?
10) God’s Role: Why Let Abraham Argue At All?
11) Introducing Paltith: Lot’s Righteous Daughter
12) A Parable: Two Girlfriends and Sharing Grain
13) A Parable: Punishing Generosity in Sodom
14) Lot’s Wife: A Woman of Virtue?
15) A Defense for the Just?
16) Did Lot’s Family Deserve to Have Been Saved?
17) Lot’s Wife as a Compassionate Mother
18) Lot’s Daughters in the Aftermath: Saving Humankind
19) Lot in the Aftermath: Saving a City
20) Sins of Sodom: A Warning for Today and for the Future
21) Lot’s Wife and the Heart’s Need to Look Back
Names:
Key Words:
Categories:
Tags: