In the logical theological conclusion to this series, Professor Wiesel transitions from darkness, struggle, and meaning to the choices of hope or despair, heresy or faith. In discussing what it means for a Jew to have faith today, Professor Wiesel refers to the forthcoming festival of Passover and the disturbing part in the Haggadah where God emphasises that He Himself killed the firstborns. In asking how we can reconcile so many deaths with belief in God, Professor Wiesel teaches us that we cannot invent any new argument, but we can follow in the footsteps of our predecessors: the Talmudic masters, the Hasidic rebbes, and his teacher Saul Lieberman.