The Elie Wiesel Living Archive

at The 92nd Street Y, New York. Supported by The Elie Wiesel Foundation for Humanity

Israel: New Fears, Old Hopes

The Relationship Between the Shoah and Israel: The Secret of Jewish History Beginning Again

May 01, 2008

On Yom HaShoah and a week before Yom Ha’Atzmaut, Professor Wiesel addresses fear and hope from a historical and contemporary perspective. In particular, Professor Wiesel speaks of the relationship between the Shoah and the State of Israel. He questions whether the Shoah would have happened had Israel existed and whether Israel would exist had there been no Shoah. To both, he answers with a resolute no, but penetrates the connection between the two events not just chronologically, but philosophically. Ultimately, Professor Wiesel prefers to credit the establishment of the Jewish State to the Jewish people who always kept Jewish memory and hope alive. Professor Wiesel insists also on taking present threats against Israel and the Jewish people seriously. Those who reject the existence of the Holocaust of the past, want a Holocaust in the future. Professor Wiesel concludes with two personal stories: his fear in Auschwitz that he was witnessing the end of Jewish history and his hopes when witnessing the Old City of Jerusalem in 1967. Jewish history did not end in Auschwitz but found the secret of beginning again.

Selected Quotes:
Subthemes:
1) The thin line between fear and love, hope and fear
2) Fear at Mt. Sinai
3) Missing a 92Y lecture due to an Israel trip
4) Would Israel exist without the Holocaust?
5) A self-examination regarding Israel after 60 years
6) To whom do we owe our gratitude for Israel?
7) Visiting and revisiting the same city for the first time
8) Hatred from Gaza and threats from Ahmadinejad, the #1 Holocaust denier
9) Difficult relations with and Holocaust history according to Arabs and Muslims
10) Does Israel embrace or resist suffering?
11) Will there be peace?
12) Jewish renaissance and the re-emergence of Israel
13) What do we do about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
14) Hatred and suicide bombing: the need to end terrorism
15) Jewish history did not end at Auschwitz but found the secret of beginning again.
Names:
Key Words:
Categories:
Tags: